# Workflow & Repository Audit

> Generated: 2025-12-31
> Purpose: Document findings and recommendations for repository improvements

## Executive Summary

This audit identifies issues in the CI/CD pipeline, versioning system, and repository structure. The goal is to prevent bugs like the install.sh non-interactive failure and make the repository easier to navigate.

---

## Part 1: CI/CD & Versioning Analysis

### Current Workflow Architecture

```
PR Creation/Update
├── pr-checks.yml (title validation, build check)
├── validate-registry.yml (component detection)
├── validate-test-suites.yml (JSON validation)
└── installer-checks.yml [NEW] (install.sh tests)

PR Merge → Main
├── post-merge-pr.yml (version bump PR creation)
├── update-registry.yml (auto-detect components)
└── sync-docs.yml (documentation updates)

Version Bump PR Merge
└── create-release.yml (tag + GitHub release)
```

### Versioning Flow

1. PR merged with conventional commit title
2. `post-merge-pr.yml` detects bump type from commit message
3. Creates version bump branch + PR with `version-bump` label
4. On merge, `create-release.yml` creates tag and GitHub release
5. VERSION file and package.json stay synchronized

### Issues Identified

| Issue | Severity | Status |
|-------|----------|--------|
| No CI for install.sh changes | High | **FIXED** (installer-checks.yml) |
| Disabled workflow file exists | Low | Needs cleanup |
| Complex loop prevention logic | Medium | Document better |
| OpenCode sync dependency | Medium | Add fallback |
| Multiple skip patterns scattered | Medium | Consider centralizing |

### Recommendations

1. **Remove `post-merge.yml.disabled`** - Causes confusion
2. **Add workflow concurrency controls** - Prevent race conditions
3. **Document skip patterns** - Create reference for maintainers
4. **Add health check workflow** - Weekly validation of system integrity

---

## Part 2: Repository Structure Analysis

### Current Structure

```
/
├── README.md (600+ lines)
├── QUICK_START.md
├── install.sh, update.sh
├── registry.json, package.json
├── docs/ (comprehensive)
├── scripts/ (26+ scripts in 7 subdirs)
├── evals/ (evaluation framework)
├── .opencode/ (agent components)
├── .github/ (workflows + templates)
├── dev/ (development tools)
├── src/ (minimal, possibly unused)
└── assets/ (images)
```

### Issues Identified

| Issue | Impact | Recommendation |
|-------|--------|----------------|
| Multiple entry points (README, QUICK_START, docs/) | High | Consolidate |
| Root directory clutter (20+ files) | Medium | Organize into subdirs |
| Overlapping documentation | Medium | Single source of truth |
| Orphaned `src/` directory | Low | Evaluate or remove |
| Multiple config files without clear hierarchy | Medium | Document purposes |

### Recommended Structure (Non-Breaking)

```
/
├── README.md (streamlined ~200 lines)
├── install.sh (keep at root for curl access)
├── VERSION, LICENSE, Makefile
│
├── docs/
│   ├── README.md (comprehensive hub)
│   ├── getting-started/ (moved QUICK_START here)
│   ├── guides/
│   └── reference/
│
├── scripts/
│   ├── README.md (index of all scripts)
│   ├── install/ (installation related)
│   ├── testing/ (all tests)
│   ├── development/ (dev workflows)
│   └── maintenance/ (cleanup, validation)
│
├── config/ [NEW]
│   ├── registry.json
│   └── env.example
│
└── ... (rest unchanged)
```

---

## Part 3: Action Items

### Immediate (This PR)

- [x] Fix install.sh non-interactive bug
- [x] Add installer-checks.yml workflow
- [x] Add test-non-interactive.sh
- [x] Add test-e2e-install.sh
- [x] Fix CHANGELOG.md duplicates
- [x] Update registry.json metadata

### Short-Term (Next Sprint)

- [ ] Streamline main README.md
- [ ] Move QUICK_START.md to docs/getting-started/
- [ ] Document all skip patterns in one place
- [ ] Remove post-merge.yml.disabled
- [ ] Add workflow concurrency controls

### Medium-Term (Future)

- [ ] Create config/ directory structure
- [ ] Consolidate script organization
- [ ] Add weekly health check workflow
- [ ] Evaluate and clean up src/ directory
- [ ] Add local CI testing script

---

## Part 4: Prevention Measures

### For Install Script Bugs

The new `installer-checks.yml` workflow prevents future install.sh bugs by:

1. **ShellCheck** - Static analysis catches common shell issues
2. **Syntax validation** - Ensures scripts are parseable
3. **Non-interactive tests** - Validates `curl | bash` scenarios
4. **E2E tests** - Full installation workflow validation
5. **Multi-platform** - Tests on Ubuntu and macOS
6. **Profile smoke tests** - All profiles tested non-interactively

### For Workflow Issues

Consider adding:

```yaml
# Prevent concurrent runs on same branch
concurrency:
  group: ${{ github.workflow }}-${{ github.ref }}
  cancel-in-progress: false
```

### For Documentation Drift

- Use cross-references instead of duplicating content
- Add CI check for broken internal links
- Consider documentation linting

---

## Appendix: Files Changed in This Audit

### New Files
- `.github/workflows/installer-checks.yml`
- `scripts/tests/test-non-interactive.sh`
- `scripts/tests/test-e2e-install.sh`
- `.github/WORKFLOW_AUDIT.md` (this file)

### Modified Files
- `install.sh` (bug fix for non-interactive collision handling)
- `scripts/tests/README.md` (updated test documentation)
- `CHANGELOG.md` (fixed duplicates, added 0.5.1)
- `registry.json` (updated lastUpdated metadata)
